Wiki / Walletless Escrow System

⚖️ Walletless Escrow System

Intermediate ⏱️ 12-15 minutes Important Updated: December 2025

Understanding DrugHub's innovative smart contract escrow - how it works, dispute resolution, and why it prevents exit scams. Learn why DrugHub Market's walletless design provides superior security compared to traditional darknet marketplace escrow systems.

Wallet escrow icon representing DrugHub's secure walletless escrow system for Monero transactions
✅ DrugHub uses Walletless Escrow: Your funds never sit in a market wallet. This prevents exit scams by design.

🤝 What is Escrow?

Escrow is a financial arrangement where a third party holds and regulates payment of funds between two parties conducting a transaction.

How Traditional Market Escrow Works

  1. Buyer deposits funds to market wallet
  2. Market holds funds (centralized)
  3. Vendor ships product
  4. Buyer confirms receipt
  5. Market releases funds to vendor

❌ Problem with Traditional Escrow

Market admins control all funds. They can:

  • Exit scam (steal all funds and disappear)
  • Selectively scam large amounts
  • Get hacked (all funds lost)
  • Be seized by law enforcement

💎 DrugHub's Walletless Escrow

DrugHub uses an innovative Walletless Escrow System powered by Monero smart contracts and multi-signature technology.

How It Works

Step 1: Order Creation

When you place an order:

  • DrugHub generates a unique multi-signature escrow address
  • This address requires 2 of 3 signatures to release funds:
    • Your signature (buyer)
    • Vendor's signature
    • DrugHub's signature (mediator)
  • You send XMR directly to this escrow address
  • Important: DrugHub admins CANNOT access these funds alone

Step 2: Product Shipment

  • Vendor sees payment in escrow
  • Vendor ships product
  • Order status: "Shipped"

Step 3: Successful Delivery (Normal Scenario)

  • You receive package
  • You click "Finalize Order"
  • Your signature + Vendor's signature = Funds released
  • Vendor receives payment
  • DrugHub takes small commission

Step 4: Dispute (If Problems Occur)

  • You open dispute
  • DrugHub mediator reviews evidence
  • Mediator decides fair outcome
  • Mediator's signature + Your/Vendor's signature = Resolution

Why This Prevents Exit Scams

DrugHub admins physically cannot steal your money because:

  • Funds locked in multi-signature escrow
  • Requires 2 of 3 signatures (admin signature alone = useless)
  • No central wallet holding everyone's funds
  • Each order has separate escrow contract
  • Smart contract code is immutable

Even if DrugHub is compromised or shut down, your funds in active escrows remain safe until resolved.

📊 Order Lifecycle

Order Statuses

🟡 Pending Payment

  • Order created but not funded
  • Send XMR to escrow address provided
  • Wait for 10 confirmations (~20 minutes)

🟠 Processing

  • Payment confirmed in escrow
  • Vendor preparing/packing order
  • Usually 1-3 days

🟢 Shipped

  • Vendor marked order as shipped
  • Package in transit
  • Tracking provided (if applicable)
  • Auto-finalize countdown started (usually 14 days)

✅ Completed

  • You finalized order manually
  • OR auto-finalize deadline reached
  • Funds released to vendor
  • Leave review

❌ Disputed

  • Issue with order
  • Mediator reviewing
  • Provide evidence
  • Wait for resolution

🔄 Refunded

  • Order canceled or dispute resolved in your favor
  • Full or partial refund issued
  • Funds returned to your wallet

✅ Order Finalization

Manual Finalization (Recommended)

When you receive your order and are satisfied:

  1. Login to DrugHub
  2. Go to Orders → Active Orders
  3. Find the order
  4. Click "Finalize Order"
  5. Confirm (may require PIN/2FA)
  6. Funds released to vendor
  7. Leave review
💡 Best Practice: Finalize as soon as you receive and verify the product. This builds vendor relationships and they'll prioritize future orders from you.

Auto-Finalization

If you don't manually finalize, orders auto-finalize after a set period (typically 14 days after "Shipped" status).

Why Auto-Finalize Exists:

  • Prevents buyers from holding funds indefinitely
  • Vendors need to receive payment eventually
  • Protects against buyers who receive product but don't finalize
⚠️ NEVER Finalize Early (FE)
  • Some vendors request "Finalize Early" before shipping
  • This releases funds immediately = NO ESCROW PROTECTION
  • Only FE for extremely trusted vendors with 1000+ sales
  • NEVER FE for new vendors or first orders

⚖️ Dispute Resolution

When to Open a Dispute

  • Package didn't arrive after expected delivery time + 7 days
  • Wrong product received
  • Product significantly different from description
  • Damaged/tampered package
  • Incorrect quantity
  • Vendor not responding to messages

How to Open a Dispute

  1. Try messaging vendor first (many issues resolved this way)
  2. If no response after 48 hours or unresolved:
    • Go to Orders → Active Orders
    • Click order
    • Click "Open Dispute"
  3. Fill dispute form:
    • Reason: Select appropriate reason
    • Details: Explain issue clearly and professionally
    • Evidence: Upload photos, screenshots, tracking info
    • Desired outcome: Full refund, partial refund, reship
  4. Submit dispute

Dispute Process

  1. Dispute Opened: Both parties notified
  2. Evidence Phase: You and vendor present evidence
    • Buyer provides: Photos, messages, tracking
    • Vendor provides: Shipping proof, photos, messages
  3. Mediator Review: DrugHub staff reviews
    • Usually resolved within 3-7 days
    • May request additional information
  4. Resolution: Mediator makes decision
    • 100% refund to buyer
    • 100% payment to vendor
    • Partial refund/payment split
    • Reship order
  5. Funds Released: According to decision

Common Dispute Outcomes

Buyer Wins (100% Refund)

  • No shipping proof from vendor
  • Fake tracking provided
  • Completely wrong product
  • Vendor admits fault

Vendor Wins (100% Payment)

  • Valid shipping proof provided
  • Product as described
  • Buyer unreasonable demands
  • Buyer trying to scam

Split Decision (Partial Refund)

  • Package lost in mail (not vendor's fault, but buyer didn't receive)
  • Minor discrepancy (e.g., 0.8g instead of 1g)
  • Lower quality than expected but not scam
  • Typical split: 50/50 or 70/30

💡 Dispute Tips

  • Be professional and factual
  • Provide clear evidence
  • Don't threaten or insult
  • Be patient - mediators handle many disputes
  • Most disputes favor buyers unless clear fraud attempt

💸 Fees & Commission

DrugHub Commission Structure

  • Buyer Fee: None (0%)
  • Vendor Commission: 4-7% per sale (varies by vendor level)
    • New vendors: 7%
    • Established vendors (100+ sales): 5%
    • Top vendors (1000+ sales): 4%
  • Withdrawal Fee: Network fee only (~0.001-0.01 XMR)

When Commissions Are Taken

Commissions are automatically deducted when escrow is released:

  • You pay: 100 XMR to escrow
  • Order finalized
  • Vendor receives: 95 XMR (assuming 5% commission)
  • DrugHub receives: 5 XMR commission

In disputes: Commission still applies to amount vendor receives

🔐 Security Features

Protection Against Exit Scams

  • ✅ Walletless design - no central fund pool
  • ✅ Multi-signature escrow - admins can't steal
  • ✅ Smart contract enforcement
  • ✅ Decentralized fund storage

Protection Against Vendor Scams

  • ✅ Escrow holds funds until delivery
  • ✅ Dispute system with mediators
  • ✅ Vendor bonds (vendors risk losing vendor account)
  • ✅ Review system exposes scammers

Protection Against Buyer Scams

  • ✅ Auto-finalization prevents indefinite holds
  • ✅ Shipping proof required for disputes
  • ✅ Buyer reputation system
  • ✅ Mediators detect false claims

🎯 Escrow Best Practices

  • ✅ Always use escrow - never direct deal
  • ✅ Never finalize early for new vendors
  • ✅ Finalize promptly after successful delivery
  • ✅ Open disputes before auto-finalize deadline
  • ✅ Provide clear evidence in disputes
  • ✅ Communicate with vendor before disputing
  • ✅ Read product descriptions carefully
  • ✅ Check vendor reviews before ordering
  • ❌ Don't panic if delivery is delayed
  • ❌ Don't open frivolous disputes
  • ❌ Don't finalize before receiving package
  • ❌ Don't accept offers to deal outside market

❓ Escrow FAQ

Q: How long do funds stay in escrow?

A: Until you finalize or auto-finalize period ends (typically 14 days after shipping).

Q: Can I cancel an order after funding escrow?

A: Only if vendor hasn't shipped yet. Contact vendor immediately and open a dispute if they don't respond.

Q: What if DrugHub goes down during my order?

A: Your funds remain locked in multi-signature escrow. When market returns, your order continues normally. In worst case, recovery process would be initiated.

Q: Can I get a refund for partial delivery?

A: Yes, open a dispute and explain. Mediator will typically award partial refund proportional to what's missing.

Q: How are disputed orders resolved?

A: Mediators review evidence from both parties and make fair decision. Most disputes resolved within 3-7 days.

🔬 Technical Deep Dive: Multi-Signature Escrow

Lock encryption icon representing the technical security of DrugHub's multi-signature escrow

How Multi-Signature Works in Monero

DrugHub's walletless escrow leverages Monero's multi-signature (multisig) capabilities. Unlike Bitcoin's native multisig, Monero multisig maintains privacy while enabling shared control over funds. Here's how the 2-of-3 escrow operates:

Key Generation Phase

When you place an order, three parties each generate partial keys:

  • Buyer (You): Your wallet generates a partial key for this specific escrow
  • Vendor: Their wallet generates a partial key
  • DrugHub (Mediator): The market generates a partial key

These partial keys are combined to create a unique escrow address. No single party controls this address - it requires cooperation of at least two parties.

Fund Locking

When you send XMR to the escrow address:

  • Funds are cryptographically locked to the 2-of-3 multisig address
  • No individual party can move the funds alone
  • The transaction appears as a normal Monero transaction on the blockchain
  • DrugHub monitors for incoming payments and updates order status

Release Mechanisms

Funds can only be released through specific combinations:

  • Buyer + Vendor: Normal finalization (buyer satisfied, finalizes order)
  • Buyer + DrugHub: Dispute resolved in buyer's favor
  • Vendor + DrugHub: Dispute resolved in vendor's favor, or auto-finalize

Cryptographic Security Guarantees on DrugHub Market

The mathematical properties of DrugHub's multisig provide strong security guarantees:

  • Collusion Resistance: Even if DrugHub Market admins are malicious, they cannot steal funds without cooperation from either buyer or vendor
  • Transparency: All parties can verify escrow address derivation
  • No Central Point of Failure: Compromise of DrugHub's infrastructure alone cannot result in fund theft
  • Audit Trail: The blockchain records when funds move, though amounts and parties remain private
Technical Note: Monero's multisig requires interactive key exchange between parties. DrugHub automates this process through the order system, so you don't need to manually coordinate with vendors.

📊 Comparing Escrow Models

Traditional Centralized Escrow (Most Markets)

Most darknet markets use centralized escrow where the market holds all funds:

Centralized Escrow Risks

  • Exit Scam: Admins can disappear with all funds at any time
  • Hack Target: Centralized hot wallets are attractive targets
  • Selective Scamming: Admins can steal from large orders
  • Law Enforcement Seizure: Seized markets result in total fund loss
  • History: Evolution, Sheep Marketplace, Wall Street Market all exit scammed

DrugHub's Walletless Escrow

DrugHub's approach fundamentally changes the trust model:

Walletless Escrow Benefits

  • Exit Scam Impossible: Admins physically cannot access funds alone
  • No Hot Wallet: No centralized target for hackers
  • Distributed Risk: Each order is a separate escrow contract
  • Seizure Resistant: Law enforcement cannot seize what's not centrally held
  • Mathematically Enforced: Security is cryptographic, not promise-based

Trust Comparison Table

Feature Traditional DrugHub
Admin can steal funds Yes No
Single hack can drain all Yes No
LE seizure = total loss Yes No
Trust requirement High (trust admins) Low (trust math)

🎭 Real-World Scenarios

Scenario 1: Normal Transaction

You: Order product, send 0.5 XMR to escrow address

Escrow: Funds locked in 2-of-3 multisig

Vendor: Sees payment, ships product

You: Receive package, click "Finalize"

Result: Your signature + Vendor's signature releases funds to vendor

DrugHub's role: Facilitates process but doesn't touch funds

Scenario 2: Package Never Arrives

You: 14 days pass, no package

Action: Open dispute with evidence (order date, expected delivery)

Vendor: Provides shipping proof (or cannot)

Mediator: Reviews - if vendor has no proof, rules in your favor

Result: DrugHub signature + Your signature releases funds back to you

Scenario 3: Product Quality Issue

You: Receive product, quality is 50% of advertised

Action: Open dispute with photos, lab test results if applicable

Vendor: Disputes claim or offers partial refund

Mediator: Reviews evidence, decides 50% refund appropriate

Result: Split release - 50% to you, 50% to vendor

Scenario 4: DrugHub Gets Seized

Event: Law enforcement seizes DrugHub infrastructure

Traditional Market: All funds in hot wallet seized - total loss

DrugHub: Funds remain in individual multisig escrows

Recovery: Community-driven recovery process can be initiated

Result: Users retain control over their funds through multisig keys

🎯 Advanced Dispute Strategies

Security shield icon representing dispute protection strategies on DrugHub Market

Building a Strong Dispute Case

If you need to open a dispute, preparation is key to a favorable outcome:

Documentation from Day One

  • Screenshot order confirmation immediately after placing
  • Save all messages with vendor (encrypted copies if possible)
  • Note expected delivery timeframe based on vendor's listing
  • Keep tracking information if provided

Evidence That Wins Disputes

  • Photos: Unopened package (showing postmark), contents, weight on scale
  • Timestamps: Photos should include date/time visible
  • Comparisons: Product next to listing description
  • Testing: Reagent test results for substance verification
  • Communication: Screenshots of vendor conversations

What to Avoid

  • Threatening vendors - this hurts your case
  • Making claims you can't prove
  • Opening dispute before giving vendor chance to respond
  • Accepting "off-market" resolution offers
  • Destroying evidence (keep package, contents until resolution)

Understanding DrugHub Mediator Perspective

DrugHub Market mediators aim for fair outcomes. Understanding their decision framework helps:

  • Burden of Proof: Generally shifts based on claim type
    • Non-delivery: Vendor must prove shipping
    • Wrong product: Buyer must prove discrepancy
    • Quality issues: Evidence from both sides weighted
  • Reputation History: Both parties' history is considered
  • Response Quality: Clear, professional communication favors your case
  • Evidence Quality: Verifiable, timestamped evidence is strongest

❓ Extended FAQ

Q: What happens to my funds if I lose my DrugHub account access?

A: Funds in pending escrow remain locked until the order resolves (finalization or auto-finalize). If you regain account access before auto-finalize, you can finalize normally. Contact DrugHub support for account recovery options.

Q: Can vendors see my real identity through escrow?

A: No. The escrow system uses Monero's privacy features. Vendors only see the encrypted shipping address you provide. They cannot link your payment to your real identity through the escrow transaction.

Q: Is there a minimum or maximum escrow amount?

A: Minimum is typically set by vendors (usually equivalent to $10-20). Maximum depends on vendor's escrow limit, which increases with their trust level. Top vendors may handle large orders; new vendors have lower limits.

Q: What if I accidentally finalize before receiving?

A: Once finalized, funds are released and cannot be reversed through the escrow system. Contact the vendor directly - reputable vendors often work to resolve issues even post-finalization. This is why we emphasize: never finalize before confirming receipt.

Q: How does escrow handle international orders with long shipping times?

A: The auto-finalize timer accounts for international shipping. If you're concerned about timing, message the vendor to confirm expected delivery window. You can open a dispute to pause auto-finalize if shipping is legitimately delayed.

Q: Are escrow transaction fees taken from buyer or vendor?

A: Buyers pay no escrow fees. The commission (4-7%) comes from the vendor's payout when escrow releases. Network fees for the release transaction are also covered by the commission.